BigCommerce vs Format
Side-by-side comparison — pricing, features, ratings, use cases. Find which Website Builders fits you best.
💰 Pricing
🔧 Features
📋 Assessment
💪 Strengths
- One of the biggest advantages is the zero transaction fee policy across all plans when using most approved gateways. While Shopify charges a 0.5% to 2% fee unless you use Shop Pay, BigCommerce allows you to use Stripe, PayPal, or Authorize.net without any extra charge. This can save merchants thousands of dollars annually, especially at higher volume levels, making the higher plan costs more palatable.
- The built-in feature set is remarkably comprehensive. You get unlimited products, SSL, custom domain, blog support, and advanced SEO tools (custom URLs, auto-generated sitemaps, meta tags) without needing a paid app. Multi-channel selling to Amazon, eBay, and social media platforms is also native, saving on app costs and simplifying inventory management across channels.
- BigCommerce's B2B capabilities are a standout, often requiring an enterprise plan on other platforms. You can create customer groups with tiered pricing, set up net terms for invoicing, and offer quick reorder functionality — all via the admin panel. This makes it an ideal choice for wholesalers or hybrid retailers who need wholesale and retail in one store.
- The new overage model on the Scale plan is a thoughtful response to the pain of forced plan upgrades. Instead of jumping from a flat $399 to $1,499 when you exceed $2M in GMV, you pay 0.9% of the excess. This allows high-volume merchants to scale their costs more gradually, aligning expenses with revenue growth.
- BigCommerce offers excellent API access and a developer-friendly environment. The platform's headless commerce capabilities, including a robust storefront API and integration with WordPress or other frontends, give developers the flexibility to build custom experiences. This is a reason why many brands choose BigCommerce over more rigid, template-driven rivals.
⚠ Watch out for
- The Open Payment Provider fee is a hidden cost that can catch merchants off guard. On the Core plan, if you use a payment gateway that isn't on BigCommerce's approved list, you'll pay up to 2% of the transaction amount. This fee drops to 1% on Growth and 0.5% on Scale, but for a small store on Core, this can materially increase payment processing costs, especially if they prefer certain PSPs.
- GMV caps remain a significant concern for growing stores. Despite the overage option on Scale, the automatic plan upgrade thresholds are strict: $50K on Core, $200K on Growth, and $2M on Scale. A merchant crossing these limits faces a steep monthly jump, and the overage on Scale still adds up for large operations. Fast-growing businesses should model these costs carefully to avoid surprise bills.
- Phone support is only available on the Scale and Performance plans. Core and Growth users must rely on live chat, email, and the knowledge base. For merchants who prefer immediate, spoken assistance over chat, this is a notable drawback, particularly when dealing with urgent issues like payment gateway hiccups or site downtime.
- The user interface can feel cluttered and complex compared to the simplicity of Wix or Squarespace. The admin panel is packed with settings and options, which is great for power users but overwhelming for beginners. The learning curve is steep, and you'll likely need to watch tutorials or consult the documentation to fully exploit the feature set.
- While the base feature set is generous, the app marketplace is smaller than Shopify's. You'll find fewer third-party apps, especially for specific niches like localized shipping or specialized marketing. This can limit extensibility unless you're willing to invest in custom development via the API, which may not be feasible for smaller businesses.
🎯 Best for
Merchants who want robust native ecommerce functionality, predictable payment costs on approved gateways, and a clear upgrade path from mid-size to enterprise without leaving the platform.
🚫 Who should skip
Very small sellers on a strict budget who need a free tier or minimal upfront cost, and any merchant whose payment gateway strategy requires non-approved providers that trigger the Open Payment Provider fee.
📚 Learning curve
Moderate — building a basic store is straightforward, but understanding GMV caps, approved gateway lists, overage pricing, and automatic plan upgrades requires careful review before you scale.
🧑⚖️ Verdict
BigCommerce is a powerful, feature-packed ecommerce platform ideal for medium to large stores that need B2B tools or multi-channel selling without per-transaction fees. If you're a small store on a tight budget, start with a free trial but be wary of the Open Payment Provider fee on Core — you may b
💰 Pricing
🔧 Features
📋 Assessment
💪 Strengths
- Format's templates are purpose-built for visual portfolios. Unlike generic builders, each template is designed to showcase images and videos with generous spacing, full-bleed layouts, and minimal distraction. For a photographer or designer, this means your work immediately looks high-end without spending hours adjusting margins and typography.
- The drag-and-drop editor is refreshingly straightforward. It avoids the complex grids and overlapping layers found in tools like Wix, instead offering a simple, intuitive interface where you click, drag, and edit. You can have a professional-looking site live in an afternoon, even if you have zero coding experience. This low barrier to entry is a significant advantage for busy creatives.
- Integrated client galleries are a game-changer for professional photographers. You can upload a full photoshoot, create a private gallery, invite a client to view and select favorites, and even deliver final images directly through the platform. This streamlines the entire workflow, eliminating the need for third-party services like Pixieset or ShootProof.
- Format includes e-commerce capabilities, allowing you to sell prints or digital downloads. While this comes on higher-tier plans, it's a seamless way to monetize your work. You can set up a store, connect a payment gateway (like Stripe or PayPal), and manage sales—all without leaving the builder.
- The platform integrates with essential tools like Adobe Lightroom, Folio, and Dropbox, making it easy to import and sync your work. For photographers, the Lightroom plugin directly publishes from Lightroom to Format, saving time and ensuring your portfolio is always up to date.
⚠ Watch out for
- The lack of a free tier is a significant barrier for hobbyists or those testing the waters. While a 14-day trial is generous, it's not enough to fully explore the platform's potential, and you must provide payment information to start. After the trial, you're forced to subscribe, which could deter casual users.
- Template customization is limited. While the templates are beautiful, you cannot easily change core design elements like the site's grid structure or the layout container's width. If you want to break the mold and create a truly unique design, you'll find the constraints frustrating. There's no access to HTML/CSS unless you're on a premium plan, and even then, options are restricted.
- E-commerce features are paywalled. To sell prints or digital downloads, you must upgrade to the 'Pro' plan or higher. This adds a hidden cost if you discover you need to monetize your portfolio later. The basic 'Lite' plan only allows a single product, which is not practical for a real store.
- The app's performance can be slow when handling large image libraries. Uploading and organizing hundreds of high-resolution images within the editor can lag, making the experience frustrating. This is particularly problematic for photographers who shoot in RAW and want to display high-res images without compression.
- Customer support is limited to email and a help center, with no live chat or phone support. Response times can be slow, particularly during peak hours. If you're on a deadline and need immediate help, this can be a source of anxiety.
🎯 Best for
Photographers, fine artists, and designers who want a beautiful, minimal portfolio site quickly without dealing with code or complex setup.
🚫 Who should skip
Bloggers, online store owners who need robust e-commerce, or people who want complete design control and a large plugin ecosystem.
📚 Learning curve
Minimal - the drag-and-drop editor is intuitive, and most users can set up a polished portfolio within a few hours.
🧑⚖️ Verdict
Format is the go-to choice for photographers and visual artists who want a no-code, professional portfolio without technical headaches. Its client galleries and e-commerce features are standout integrations that streamline creative workflows. However, if you require a free plan, deep customization,
📊 Use Case Suitability
Higher score = better fit. Scores from editorial review.
🧭 Which One Should You Pick?
Choose BigCommerce if...
- You are: Merchants who want robust native ecommerce functionality, predictable payment costs on approved gateways, and a clear up
- 👍 No transaction fees on most approved payment gateways across all plans, which can significantly lowe
- 👍 Strong built-in ecommerce feature set including unlimited products, SSL, custom domain, blog support
- 👍 Clear tier progression with annual billing discounts, and Scale's 0.9% overage model provides a more
- 💰 From $39/mo
- ⚠ Trade-off: Open Payment Provider fee up to 2% on Core can eat into margins if you rely on p
Choose Format if...
- You are: Photographers, fine artists, and designers who want a beautiful, minimal portfolio site quickly without dealing with cod
- 👍 Highly visual, responsive templates purpose-built for photography, design, and art portfolios
- 👍 No-code drag-and-drop editor with a straightforward interface that requires little technical skill
- 👍 Built-in client galleries, proofing tools, and delivery options that streamline photographer workflo
- 💰 From $12/mo
- ⚠ Trade-off: No free tier; after a 14-day trial you must pay for a plan, which can be a deter
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Does BigCommerce charge transaction fees?
BigCommerce charges no transaction fees on most approved payment gateways. However, orders processed outside its approved gateway list trigger an Open Payment Provider fee of up to 2%, depending on your plan.
What is the Open Payment Provider fee?
It's a fee BigCommerce applies when you process orders through a payment provider that is not on its approved gateway list. The fee is up to 2% on Core, 1% on Growth, 0.6% on Scale, and zero on Performance.
What happens when I exceed my plan's sales limit?
BigCommerce automatically upgrades your plan based on trailing 12-month GMV. On the Scale plan, you pay a 0.9% overage on GMV above $33,333 per month, and once your trailing 12-month GMV reaches $2 million, you're moved to Performance pricing.
Is SSL and a custom domain included?
Yes, SSL is included on all plans and you can connect a custom domain. BigCommerce does not have a free tier, though.
🔗 More Website Builders Comparisons
🔀 Explore Alternatives
📧 Save this comparison
We'll email you a link to this comparison. No spam.