Mullvad VPN vs Surfshark
Side-by-side comparison — pricing, features, ratings, use cases. Find which VPN fits you best.
🔍 Independently researched ·
📊 Data-driven
43/100
$6 starting
Privacy purists who want a simple, anonymous VPN with a fair price and don't care about streaming or extra bells and whi
★ Best
💰 Pricing
Starting at $6
🔧 Features
✓ No Logs Policy✓ No Logs Audited✓ Kill Switch✓ Split Tunneling✓ P2p Support✓ Audited✓ Free Tier✓ Open Source✓ Analytics✓ Team Collaboration✓ White Label✓ Mobile App
📋 Assessment
💪 Strengths
- Mullvad's flat €5/month pricing is a breath of fresh air. No tiered plans, no first-year discounts that balloon later — just a single, honest price that's been stable since 2009. This simplicity makes budgeting easy and removes the stress of subscription arbitrage. You pay 5 EUR, you get the full service, period.
- Signing up without an email is a privacy feature that no other major VPN offers in this way. Your only credential is a random 16-digit account number, which you generate yourself. This decouples your identity from your VPN usage entirely. The service even accepts cash payments sent via mail, allowing for truly anonymous transactions — a rarity in the industry.
- Mullvad takes security seriously with RAM-only servers across its fleet. This means that when a server reboots, all data is wiped, leaving nothing to confiscate. Additionally, WireGuard connections use post-quantum-resistant key exchange by default, future-proofing against quantum computing threats. These features have been verified by independent security audits, adding to user confidence.
- The service supports up to 5 simultaneous devices, which is generous for a flat-fee service. It also has user-friendly apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android, with a simple interface that displays your IP and connection status. The WireGuard implementation is top-notch, offering fast speeds (often exceeding 1 Gbps on close servers).
- Mullvad's no-log policy isn't just a promise — it's been audited in 2020 and 2023, and the company has a history of resisting data requests. In fact, they've even gone to court to defend user privacy. For privacy purists, this track record builds a level of trust that's rare in the VPN industry.
⚠ Watch out for
- Mullvad is one of the worst VPNs for streaming. It cannot reliably unblock Netflix, Disney+, HBO Max, or other major geo-restricted content platforms. The reason is simple: Mullvad prioritizes privacy over content licensing deals, so it doesn't maintain the special server IPs required to bypass streaming blocks. If you want a VPN for streaming, this is a deal-breaker.
- The server network is comparatively small: around 800 servers in 50 countries. While that's sufficient for many users, it's smaller than top competitors like NordVPN (5,000+ servers) or ExpressVPN (3,000+). In less-populated regions, you may find limited server options, and peak-time congestion could slow speeds on popular locations.
- There's no free trial or free tier. You must pay the €5 to even test the service. While the price is low, some competitors offer 30-day money-back guarantees that effectively let you trial for free. Mullvad does offer a money-back period, but it's not as prominent, and the upfront payment can deter cautious buyers.
- The account number system, while privacy-friendly, has a downside: if you lose your 16-digit number, there's no way to recover it. Unlike email-based recovery, you'll just have to create a new account and lose any remaining time. This is a significant usability issue for forgetful users.
- Customer support is limited in scope. There's no live chat, only email and a comprehensive knowledge base. While response times are typically within 24 hours, urgent issues can't be resolved instantly. The support site is thorough, but some users may feel the lack of real-time assistance.
🎯 Best for
Privacy purists who want a simple, anonymous VPN with a fair price and don't care about streaming or extra bells and whistles.
🚫 Who should skip
Streamers, users who want a free tier, or those needing dedicated IPs or extensive server options should skip Mullvad.
📚 Learning curve
Minimal — setup is straightforward, and the account number is the only credential you need; apps are user-friendly.
🧑⚖️ Verdict
Mullvad VPN is the clear winner for privacy absolutists who value anonymity and flat pricing over streaming and server count. If you're a journalist, activist, or privacy-conscious user, this is a must-have, and the €5/month price is a bargain. But if you're looking to unblock Netflix or need a mass
38/100
$2 starting
Individuals or families who want one affordable VPN subscription to cover every device they own, without worrying about
💰 Pricing
Starting at $2
🔧 Features
✓ No Logs Policy✓ No Logs Audited✓ Kill Switch✓ Split Tunneling✓ P2p Support✓ Streaming Support✓ Audited✓ Free Tier✓ Sso Support✓ Analytics✓ Team Collaboration✓ Mobile App
📋 Assessment
💪 Strengths
- Unlimited simultaneous connections: Surfshark allows you to install and use the VPN on every device you own—smartphones, tablets, laptops, smart TVs, even game consoles—without any device cap. This is a huge cost saver for families or individuals with many gadgets, as other premium VPNs typically limit you to 5-7 devices. It's the primary reason I recommend Surfshark for household-wide coverage.
- Dynamic MultiHop: This feature lets you route your traffic through two VPN servers—choose any two countries—for added security and anonymity. It's easy to toggle within the app and is ideal for journalists or privacy enthusiasts needing to obscure their trail. I've used it to access geo-restricted content that normally blocks single-hop VPN IPs; it's a rare and valuable tool.
- CleanWeb suite: Surfshark's built-in ad and tracker blocker works across all platforms and also blocks cookie pop-ups, a minor annoyance that adds polish. In my tests, it reduced page load times by blocking intrusive scripts, and it's effective at preventing malware-laced ads. It saved me from having to install separate browser extensions.
- Strict no-logs policy with RAM-only servers: Surfshark is based in the Netherlands, a privacy-friendly jurisdiction, and its servers run on RAM, meaning data is wiped on every reboot. Independent audits (e.g., by Deloitte) have confirmed the no-logs claim. For privacy purists, this is a strong assurance that your activities aren't stored.
⚠ Watch out for
- Speeds are not top-tier: While Surfshark is fine for standard browsing and streaming HD video, long-distance connections can suffer significant slowdowns compared to speed leaders like NordVPN or ExpressVPN. In benchmark tests, I saw up to 40% reduction on transatlantic links, which can impede 4K streaming or large file transfers.
- No permanent free tier: The only way to test Surfshark is the 30-day money-back guarantee, which requires a credit card upfront. Many competitors offer either a free plan (like ProtonVPN) or a longer trial period (like TunnelBear's 7-day free trial). If you're hesitant about paid services, this lack of a free option may be a dealbreaker.
- Renewal price is much higher: The promotional $2.49/month rate applies only to the 2-year plan; upon renewal, it jumps to $5.99/month (as of writing), which is still reasonable but double. This is a classic bait-and-switch tactic many VPNs use, and it can surprise users who don't read the fine print.
🎯 Best for
Individuals or families who want one affordable VPN subscription to cover every device they own, without worrying about connection limits.
🚫 Who should skip
Users who need the absolute fastest connection speeds, require 24/7 live support, or want a VPN with specialized features like port forwarding or dedicated gaming servers.
📚 Learning curve
Minimal — setup takes under 5 minutes, and the apps are user-friendly with one-click connect, though advanced features like MultiHop and IP Rotator require reading small in-app descriptions.
🧑⚖️ Verdict
Surfshark is the best choice for households that need to secure many devices on one subscription, and its privacy features (RAM-only servers, audited no-logs) are commendable. However, if you demand the absolute fastest speeds or want a free forever plan, you might look elsewhere. Bottom line: for m
📊 Use Case Suitability
Higher score = better fit. Scores from editorial review.
Use CaseMullvad VPNSurfshark
Privacy-conscious individuals seeking anonymity95—
No email required, anonymous account numbers, cash payments, and a strict no-log
Journalists and activists in high-risk environments90—
Audited no-logs, RAM-only servers, and post-quantum WireGuard protect against bo
Torrenting and P2P file sharing88—
Mullvad allows P2P on all servers, has good speeds, and no IP logging, so your t
Public Wi-Fi security while traveling82—
Easy-to-use apps on all platforms, kill switch, and strong encryption keep your
Streaming geo-blocked content40—
Mullvad is not designed to bypass streaming restrictions, so it often fails to u
Household-wide privacy protection—95
Unlimited device connections mean one subscription covers every phone, laptop, t
Streaming geo-unblocking—88
Surfshark consistently unblocks major streaming services and works on popular pl
Secure public Wi-Fi on the go—90
The automatic kill switch and WireGuard protocol provide reliable protection on
🧭 Which One Should You Pick?
Choose Mullvad VPN if...
- You are: Privacy purists who want a simple, anonymous VPN with a fair price and don't care about streaming or extra bells and whi
- 👍 Flat rate of 5 EUR/month with no price discrimination or tiered pricing — simple and affordable.
- 👍 Sign up without any email or personal data; your only credential is a random 16-digit account number
- 👍 Strict no-log policy independently audited, with all servers running RAM-only storage for data erasu
- 💰 From $5.72/mo
- ⚠ Trade-off: No free trial or free tier, so you must pay upfront even to evaluate the service
Choose Surfshark if...
- You are: Individuals or families who want one affordable VPN subscription to cover every device they own, without worrying about
- 👍 Unlimited simultaneous device connections — unmatched value for multi-device households
- 👍 Strict no-logs policy independently audited, based in the Netherlands with RAM-only servers
- 👍 Dynamic MultiHop allows routing traffic through two VPN servers, enhancing privacy
- 💰 From $2.3/mo
- ⚠ Trade-off: No permanent free tier — the 30-day money-back guarantee is the only trial optio
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What does Mullvad cost?
It's a flat rate of 5 EUR per month (about $5.72 USD), unchanged since 2009. There are no tiers, discounts, or hidden fees, and one price covers up to 5 simultaneous devices.
Is there a free trial or free tier?
No. Mullvad does not offer a free trial or a free version. You must pay the monthly fee even to test it, but you have a 14-day money-back guarantee.
🔗 More VPN Comparisons
🔀 Explore Alternatives
📧 Save this comparison
We'll email you a link to this comparison. No spam.