BambooHR vs Paylocity
Side-by-side comparison — pricing, features, ratings, use cases. Find which Payroll fits you best.
🔍 Independently researched ·
📊 Data-driven
· ⭐ Ratings from G2 (real user reviews)
78/100
24 zł starting
US-based SMBs with 25–500 employees that want an easy-to-use HRIS for employee records, hiring, onboarding, time-off, an
★ Best
💰 Pricing
Starting at 24 zł (subscription)
Fee notes:
- Pricing is per employee per month. Annual billing required for the listed annual rate.
- Core is $6/employee/month with annual billing, $8 monthly.
- Pro is $9/employee/month with annual billing, $12 monthly.
- Payroll add-on is not included in HRIS pricing; additional fees apply.
- Integration with payroll partners may incur separate fees from the partner.
⚠ Watch for:
- Setup fees for larger organizations or custom implementations.
- Additional fees for premium support or dedicated success manager.
- Extra costs for add-on modules like benefits administration or advanced payroll.
- Integration fees may apply when connecting to third-party payroll providers.
🔧 Features
✓ Us Smb✓ Hris✓ 30k Customers✓ Performance✓ Global
📋 Assessment
💪 Strengths
- The employee self-service portal is exceptionally intuitive. Employees can easily update their personal information, view pay history (when integrated), request time off, and access company directory, all from a clean dashboard. This reduces the number of routine questions HR receives and encourages employees to take ownership of their data, which is a huge win for small teams with limited HR staff.
- Time-off management is a standout feature. BambooHR allows you to set up multiple accrual rules based on employee type, tenure, or location, and automatically tracks PTO balances. The request approval workflow is straightforward, with managers receiving email alerts and a color-coded calendar showing who's out. This visibility prevents scheduling conflicts and makes it easy to plan for coverage, a common pain point in growing companies.
- Onboarding features are excellent. You can create digital checklists for different roles, assign required documents for e-signature (via HelloSign), and automate reminder emails to ensure new hires complete tasks on time. This ensures a consistent and professional experience for every new employee, even without a dedicated onboarding manager, and helps new hires feel productive from day one.
- The applicant tracking system (ATS) is decently integrated with hiring. You can post jobs to free and paid boards directly from BambooHR, create a careers page, and manage candidates through a visual pipeline. The resume parsing feature saves time by automatically pulling key data into the system. This integrates hiring data with employee records, making it easier to track candidate-to-hire progress and ensure a smooth transition.
- Reporting, though limited, covers essential HR metrics. You can generate reports on headcount, turnover, time-off utilization, and other standard metrics. The drag-and-drop builder is simple for non-technical users, and you can schedule reports to be emailed automatically. This is sufficient for most SMBs to track trends and make informed decisions without needing a data analyst.
⚠ Watch out for
- Payroll is not native, which is a major drawback if you're looking for an all-in-one HR and payroll solution. You'll need to subscribe to a partner like Gusto (for US-based companies) and pay an additional fee. This leads to extra costs, but also data handoff issues — employee changes in BambooHR may not sync perfectly with payroll, creating potential errors and double-entry work. For a seamless payroll experience, this is a significant limitation.
- Pricing is based on per-employee per-month, and the cost scales quickly as you grow. The core package starts at $6/employee/month, but you'll likely want add-ons like Performance Management or ATS, which can double the cost. For a 500-person company, this could easily mean $3,000+ per month, making it less cost-effective compared to competitors like Zoho People or Officient that offer bundled features at a lower price point. Be sure to calculate total cost including add-ons before committing.
- Reporting capabilities are limited compared to advanced HRIS or ERP tools. You can't create fully custom dashboards or do deep data analysis without exporting to tools like Excel or Google Sheets. The built-in reports are pre-built with limited customization options, which may frustrate HR teams that need granular insights into things like compensation analytics or true HR-to-payroll data integration. For data-heavy organizations, this could be a bottleneck.
- While the ATS is functional, it lacks the depth of dedicated recruitment software like Greenhouse or Lever. For example, it doesn't offer sophisticated interview scheduling, advanced candidate scoring, or robust integrations with job boards and third-party recruiting tools. If your company’s primary need is high-caliber talent acquisition, BambooHR’s ATS will feel basic and may require a separate ATS investment.
- The mobile app is serviceable but not game-changing. It allows basic HR tasks like time-off requests, approvals, and viewing employee information, but lacks the full functionality of the desktop version. For instance, performance review workflows and comprehensive reporting are not available on mobile. Employees who rely heavily on mobile may find it lacking, and HR admins may need to switch to a laptop for detailed tasks.
🎯 Best for
US-based SMBs with 25–500 employees that want an easy-to-use HRIS for employee records, hiring, onboarding, time-off, and performance management, and are comfortable using partner apps for payroll.
🚫 Who should skip
Larger enterprises, companies with complex payroll or global compliance needs, and growing startups on a tight budget who can't absorb per-employee pricing.
📚 Learning curve
Minimal. The interface is intuitive, and most employees can start using self-service features like time-off requests within minutes.
🧑⚖️ Verdict
BambooHR is an excellent HRIS for SMBs focused on user-friendly employee records, time-off tracking, and onboarding. It's particularly well-suited for companies that are growing and need to streamline HR processes without hiring a dedicated HR specialist. However, if you need integrated, native payr
26/100
—
Mid-size to enterprise companies (50-1,000+ employees) that need an integrated payroll, HR, benefits, and time tracking
💰 Pricing
Pricing not publicly available
Fee notes:
- Custom pricing: Paylocity does not publicly list fixed prices. Costs vary based on payroll frequency, number of employees, and selected modules.
- Implementation fee: Typically charged for setup and data migration, amount varies.
- Annual contract required in most cases.
- Additional fees for add-ons: benefits administration, time & attendance, talent management, etc.
⚠ Watch for:
- Payroll processing fees per payroll run may exceed base fee, especially for off-cycle runs.
- Fees for each W-2 or 1095-C form may be charged separately.
- Service fees for support beyond standard hours or dedicated support may apply.
- Data migration fees can be significant.
🔧 Features
✓ Payroll✓ Hr✓ Benefits✓ Talent Mgmt✓ Workforce Mgmt
📋 Assessment
💪 Strengths
- All-in-one suite eliminates the need for juggling multiple systems. With payroll, HR, benefits, talent, and workforce management all in one platform, you get seamless data flows. For example, when you approve a time-off request in the HR module, it automatically updates the employee's paycheck and PTO balance — no manual sync needed. This reduces data entry errors and saves administrative time, especially for companies that previously had to reconcile between separate payroll and HR systems.
- The mobile app is truly best-in-class. Employees can clock in and out with GPS or QR code scanning, view paystubs and W-2s, update W-4s, request PTO, and even access their 401(k) contributions. The app also supports employee recognition and social feeds, which can boost engagement. For managers, it allows approval of timecards and time-off requests on the go, so you don't have to be at your desk to run your team.
- Automated tax filing and compliance updates. Paylocity handles all federal, state, and local payroll tax filing, including new hire reporting. It automatically updates tax tables when rates change, and you can receive alerts about filing deadlines. This reduces the risk of penalties for late or incorrect filings, which can be costly. The system also supports multi-state payroll, so if you have employees in multiple states, it calculates the correct taxes for each jurisdiction.
- Powerful reporting and analytics. The built-in report suite includes over 70 pre-built reports, from standard payroll summaries to headcount trends and labor cost by department. You can also customize reports with the drag-and-drop builder. For example, you can create a report showing overtime costs by supervisor, or track benefits enrollment across locations. These insights help you make informed decisions about staffing and budgeting.
- Workforce scheduling with labor cost forecasting. The scheduling tool lets you create shift schedules, assign employees based on skills and certifications, and set shift differentials. It integrates with time tracking to show real-time labor costs versus budget, which is a huge asset for industries like hospitality and healthcare. You can also forecast labor needs based on historical traffic data, helping you avoid overstaffing or understaffing.
⚠ Watch out for
- Pricing is opaque and can get expensive. There's no public pricing; you must contact sales. Costs depend on the modules you choose and the number of employees, with per-employee monthly fees. Small businesses may find it pricey compared to competitors like Gusto or SurePayroll, especially when you add optional modules. Budget-conscious buyers should be prepared for a custom quote and potential sticker shock.
- Implementation can be lengthy and data-heavy. While the vendor provides a project manager, getting everything set up is manual and requires your team to gather employee data, benefit plans, and historical payroll info. Be prepared for a multi-week process (4-8 weeks), and you may encounter data migration hiccups, such as incomplete benefit accrual histories. If you're switching from another provider, you'll need to carefully validate the first few payroll runs.
- Customer support consistency is a concern. While some users praise the phone and chat support, others report long wait times during peak periods (like January or after tax season), and occasional cases that take days to resolve. The knowledge base is extensive but not always up to date. If you encounter a payroll deadline issue, you might find yourself on hold for longer than you'd like.
- The sheer feature set can overwhelm small teams. With so many modules, the UI can feel cluttered, and you may need to train your HR staff on multiple workflows. For companies with simple payroll needs, this complexity is unnecessary. You might find yourself paying for features you don't use.
🎯 Best for
Mid-size to enterprise companies (50-1,000+ employees) that need an integrated payroll, HR, benefits, and time tracking platform with strong tax compliance and self-service tools.
🚫 Who should skip
Very small businesses or startups that need simple, low-cost payroll with minimal HR features, and freelancers/solopreneurs who don't need comprehensive workforce management.
📚 Learning curve
Moderate — the breadth of features and customization options require training for administrators, though employee-facing tasks are mostly intuitive.
🧑⚖️ Verdict
Paylocity is a robust, all-in-one HCM platform best suited for mid-size companies (50-1000+ employees) with complex payroll needs and the resources to handle a lengthy implementation. If you're a small business with fewer than 25 employees, consider a simpler, cheaper solution like Gusto. Bottom lin
📊 Use Case Suitability
Higher score = better fit. Scores from editorial review.
Use CaseBambooHRPaylocity
Centralizing employee records for SMB HR teams92—
BambooHR's clean interface and employee database make it easy to organize, updat
Tracking time-off and leave policies90—
The time-off module is intuitive for both employees and managers, with customiza
Onboarding new hires88—
BambooHR offers structured onboarding checklists, task assignments, and electron
Running performance review cycles82—
Built-in performance review templates, self-assessments, and 360-degree feedback
Global HR management for multi-country teams30—
It can store basic records of international employees but lacks true global payr
Mid-size company payroll processing and tax compliance—92
Paylocity automates payroll calculations, tax filings, and year-end reporting, w
Unified HR and benefits administration—88
It combines HR records, benefits enrollment, payroll, and time tracking in one p
Workforce scheduling and labor cost management—85
Built-in time clocks and scheduling tools help optimize shift coverage and calcu
🧭 Which One Should You Pick?
Choose BambooHR if...
- You are: US-based SMBs with 25–500 employees that want an easy-to-use HRIS for employee records, hiring, onboarding, time-off, an
- 👍 Very user-friendly interface that employees and managers can adopt quickly without extensive trainin
- 👍 Strong time-off management with flexible accrual rules, easy request workflows, and visibility acros
- 👍 Excellent onboarding features with digital checklists, e-signatures, and automated reminders.
- 💰 From $6/mo
- ⚠ Trade-off: Payroll is not native; you often need to pay a separate partner service, which c
Choose Paylocity if...
- You are: Mid-size to enterprise companies (50-1,000+ employees) that need an integrated payroll, HR, benefits, and time tracking
- 👍 Comprehensive all-in-one platform: payroll, HR, benefits, talent, and workforce management in one pl
- 👍 Strong employee self-service mobile app that lets staff view paystubs, update W-4s, request PTO, and
- 👍 Automated tax filing and compliance updates across all 50 states, which helps reduce payroll tax pen
- ⚠ Trade-off: Pricing is opaque and can become expensive as you add modules or per-employee fe
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Is BambooHR actually free?
No. BambooHR is a paid HRIS platform with a free trial, but its pricing is quote-based and typically charged per employee per month. The 'Free' label is incorrect for full access.
Does BambooHR include payroll processing?
BambooHR does not offer native payroll for all customers; it integrates with payroll partners like Paychex and others. You usually need to purchase a separate payroll service.
Is BambooHR good for companies outside the US?
It supports global employee records but is primarily designed for US-based SMBs. Payroll compliance and HR features are US-centric, so companies in other countries may need additional local tools.
What are BambooHR's biggest limitations?
The main limitations are the lack of native payroll for many clients, per-employee pricing that gets expensive, and less robust functionality for very large enterprises or complex union/shift requirements.
🔗 More Payroll Comparisons
🔀 Explore Alternatives
📧 Save this comparison
We'll email you a link to this comparison. No spam.