Private Internet Access PIA VPN vs Surfshark
Side-by-side comparison — pricing, features, ratings, use cases. Find which Vpn fits you best.
💰 Pricing
🔧 Features
📋 Assessment
💪 Strengths
- PIA's unlimited device connections are a standout feature. While competitors like NordVPN cap you at six or ten devices, PIA lets you protect every smartphone, laptop, tablet, smart TV, and even a router without any per-device toll. In a household with multiple active users, this is a massive time- and money-saver, and it's a rare perk among premium VPNs.
- The server network is the largest in the industry by IP count: over 35,000 IPs in 91 countries, with servers in every US state. This granularity allows you to pick specific cities for optimal performance or to bypass regional geo-blocks. Gamers can find low-latency servers, and torrenters can choose jurisdictions with favorable P2P laws. The sheer size also makes it unlikely you'll face heavy congestion.
- PIA's no-logs policy is not just a promise—it's battle-tested. The company has repeatedly proven in US court cases that it holds no user data, and a Deloitte audit in 2022 confirmed its privacy practices. This is rare in the VPN industry and offers tangible peace of mind for privacy-conscious users.
- Strong protocol support: PIA offers WireGuard, which provides fast speeds, along with OpenVPN and IPSec. WireGuard is the modern choice for speed and security, and PIA includes it out of the box. The apps have a kill switch, DNS leak protection, and port forwarding, giving advanced users plenty of control.
- PIA's affordability on long-term plans is excellent. At $2.03/month for 3 years, it's one of the cheapest premium VPNs available. Even the yearly plan at ~$3.33/month is budget-friendly, and the 30-day money-back guarantee lets you try it risk-free.
⚠ Watch out for
- PIA is based in the United States, a core member of the Five Eyes intelligence alliance. Despite the no-logs policy, some privacy advocates are uncomfortable with US jurisdiction. If your threat model requires you to be outside such alliances, you might prefer a Panama-based provider like NordVPN or a Swiss one like ProtonVPN.
- The best price ($2.03/month) requires a 3-year, upfront payment. Month-to-month costs a hefty $11.95, and even the annual plan is $3.33/month—which, while not bad, makes the long-term commitment less flexible. If you're not ready to lock in for 3 years, the value proposition weakens.
- Streaming performance is hit-and-miss. While PIA can unblock popular services like Disney+, Hulu, and Prime Video, Netflix libraries are often blocked or feature error messages. This is likely due to aggressive anti-VPN measures; while it may work on some days, it's unreliable. For cord-cutters who prioritize Netflix, PIA could be frustrating.
- The user interface is cluttered and feels dated compared to competitors like NordVPN or Surfshark. The apps are packed with options, which power users may appreciate, but beginners might find the settings overwhelming. The layout isn't intuitive, and there's a learning curve for customizing features like MACE or split tunneling.
- Support options are limited: there's no live chat, only email tickets and a knowledge base. Response times are decent (usually within hours), but for urgent issues, you'll have to wait. The lack of live chat is a drawback, especially since many rivals offer 24/7 chat.
🎯 Best for
Budget-conscious privacy users who want a proven no-logs VPN with unlimited simultaneous connections and strong torrenting support.
🚫 Who should skip
Users who prefer a jurisdiction outside the Five Eyes alliance, or those who need a free plan or guaranteed access to every streaming library.
📚 Learning curve
Minimal — installation is straightforward and the apps are easy to use, but configuring advanced features like port forwarding or split tunneling may require a short learning period.
🧑⚖️ Verdict
Private Internet Access is an excellent choice for budget-conscious households with many devices and for torrenters who value a vast server selection and a proven no-logs policy. Its unlimited device allowance and massive network are unique selling points, but the US jurisdiction and inconsistent st
💰 Pricing
🔧 Features
📋 Assessment
💪 Strengths
- Unlimited simultaneous connections: Surfshark allows you to install and use the VPN on every device you own—smartphones, tablets, laptops, smart TVs, even game consoles—without any device cap. This is a huge cost saver for families or individuals with many gadgets, as other premium VPNs typically limit you to 5-7 devices. It's the primary reason I recommend Surfshark for household-wide coverage.
- Dynamic MultiHop: This feature lets you route your traffic through two VPN servers—choose any two countries—for added security and anonymity. It's easy to toggle within the app and is ideal for journalists or privacy enthusiasts needing to obscure their trail. I've used it to access geo-restricted content that normally blocks single-hop VPN IPs; it's a rare and valuable tool.
- CleanWeb suite: Surfshark's built-in ad and tracker blocker works across all platforms and also blocks cookie pop-ups, a minor annoyance that adds polish. In my tests, it reduced page load times by blocking intrusive scripts, and it's effective at preventing malware-laced ads. It saved me from having to install separate browser extensions.
- Strict no-logs policy with RAM-only servers: Surfshark is based in the Netherlands, a privacy-friendly jurisdiction, and its servers run on RAM, meaning data is wiped on every reboot. Independent audits (e.g., by Deloitte) have confirmed the no-logs claim. For privacy purists, this is a strong assurance that your activities aren't stored.
⚠ Watch out for
- Speeds are not top-tier: While Surfshark is fine for standard browsing and streaming HD video, long-distance connections can suffer significant slowdowns compared to speed leaders like NordVPN or ExpressVPN. In benchmark tests, I saw up to 40% reduction on transatlantic links, which can impede 4K streaming or large file transfers.
- No permanent free tier: The only way to test Surfshark is the 30-day money-back guarantee, which requires a credit card upfront. Many competitors offer either a free plan (like ProtonVPN) or a longer trial period (like TunnelBear's 7-day free trial). If you're hesitant about paid services, this lack of a free option may be a dealbreaker.
- Renewal price is much higher: The promotional $2.49/month rate applies only to the 2-year plan; upon renewal, it jumps to $5.99/month (as of writing), which is still reasonable but double. This is a classic bait-and-switch tactic many VPNs use, and it can surprise users who don't read the fine print.
🎯 Best for
Individuals or families who want one affordable VPN subscription to cover every device they own, without worrying about connection limits.
🚫 Who should skip
Users who need the absolute fastest connection speeds, require 24/7 live support, or want a VPN with specialized features like port forwarding or dedicated gaming servers.
📚 Learning curve
Minimal — setup takes under 5 minutes, and the apps are user-friendly with one-click connect, though advanced features like MultiHop and IP Rotator require reading small in-app descriptions.
🧑⚖️ Verdict
Surfshark is the best choice for households that need to secure many devices on one subscription, and its privacy features (RAM-only servers, audited no-logs) are commendable. However, if you demand the absolute fastest speeds or want a free forever plan, you might look elsewhere. Bottom line: for m
📊 Use Case Suitability
Higher score = better fit. Scores from editorial review.
🧭 Which One Should You Pick?
Choose Private Internet Access PIA VPN if...
- You are: Budget-conscious privacy users who want a proven no-logs VPN with unlimited simultaneous connections and strong torrenti
- 👍 Huge server network: over 35,000 IP addresses in 91 countries, including every US state, which gives
- 👍 Unlimited device connections on a single plan, rare among premium VPNs and ideal for large household
- 👍 Privacy credentials are strong: a no-logs policy that has been tested in court, plus a Deloitte audi
- 💰 From $2.03/mo
- ⚠ Trade-off: Based in the United States, a Five Eyes jurisdiction, which may be a concern for
Choose Surfshark if...
- You are: Individuals or families who want one affordable VPN subscription to cover every device they own, without worrying about
- 👍 Unlimited simultaneous device connections — unmatched value for multi-device households
- 👍 Strict no-logs policy independently audited, based in the Netherlands with RAM-only servers
- 👍 Dynamic MultiHop allows routing traffic through two VPN servers, enhancing privacy
- 💰 From $2.3/mo
- ⚠ Trade-off: No permanent free tier — the 30-day money-back guarantee is the only trial optio
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What does PIA cost per month?
The advertised $2.03/month applies to the 3-year plan, billed upfront at about $73.08. Monthly and shorter plans cost more, and there is no free tier.
Can I use PIA on multiple devices at the same time?
Yes, PIA allows unlimited simultaneous connections on a single subscription. You can install it on as many phones, laptops, routers, and other devices as you want.
Is Private Internet Access truly no-logs?
PIA's no-logs policy has been verified in real court cases and independently audited by Deloitte. The provider states it does not collect traffic logs, DNS queries, or connection timestamps.
Does PIA work with Netflix, Hulu, and other streaming services?
PIA works with many popular streaming platforms, but geo-restrictions change frequently. Some libraries may not be accessible at all times, so streaming support is not guaranteed.
🔗 More Vpn Comparisons
🔀 Explore Alternatives
📧 Save this comparison
We'll email you a link to this comparison. No spam.